Skip to content

Cart

Your cart is empty

Cleveland Guardians Trading Cards & Collectibles for Sale

Cleveland Guardians Trading Cards & Collectibles for Sale

Find Cleveland Indians Trading Cards & Collectibles Trading Cards & Collectibles for Less. 

Sort by

238 products

Filters

2018 Bowman Chrome Prospects Tyler Freeman Dual Graded Autographed Baseball Card simple Xclusive Collectibles   2018 Bowman Chrome Prospects Tyler Freeman Dual Graded Autographed Baseball Card simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Update Joey Miller #'d/2021 Gold Bordered Baseball Card AVM1 simple Xclusive Collectibles   2021 Topps Update Joey Miller #'d/2021 Gold Bordered Baseball Card AVM1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Donruss Optic Carlos Carrasco Orange Refractor Baseball Card TPTV simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Chrome Jake
  Bauers Freshman Flash  Cleveland
  Indians Baseball Card CBT1C  simple Xclusive Collectibles
2016 Topps MLB Wacky
  Packages Indians Can O’ Corn  
  Cleveland Indians Football Card VFBMB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2015 Topps American League Wins Leaders
  LL  Cleveland Indians / Detroit Tigers
  / Los Angeles Angels #214 Baseball card  
  MATV4A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Heritage 2020 AL
  HR Leaders - Mike Trout / Jose Abreu / Jose Ramirez / Luke Voit LL   Los Angeles Angels / Chicago White Sox /
  Cleveland Indians / New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021
  Topps Chrome Francisco Lindor  
  Cleveland Indians Baseball Card MLSB1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Justin Verlander /
  Trevor Bauer / Blake Snell CPC, LL   
  Houston Astros / Cleveland Indians / Tampa Bay Rays #68 Baseball
  card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Justin Verlander /
  Trevor Bauer / Blake Snell CPC, LL   
  Houston Astros / Cleveland Indians / Tampa Bay Rays #68 Baseball
  card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Heritage Gerrit
  Cole / Justin Verlander / Shane Bieber LL  
  Houston Astros / Cleveland Indians Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles   2020 Topps Heritage Gerrit
  Cole / Justin Verlander / Shane Bieber LL  
  Houston Astros / Cleveland Indians Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Donruss Aaron Civale Rookie Refractor Baseball Card TPTV simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Corey Kluber / Luis
  Severino / Blake Snell CPC, LL   
  Cleveland Indians / New York Yankees / Tampa Bay Rays #70 Baseball
  card   TMH1C_1a simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Corey Kluber / Luis
  Severino / Blake Snell CPC, LL   
  Cleveland Indians / New York Yankees / Tampa Bay Rays #70 Baseball
  card   TMH1C_1a simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Gypsy Queen Aaron Civale  Cleveland Indians #232 Baseball card   MATV4A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2016 Topps Holiday Tyler Naquin  Cleveland Indians #HMW131 Baseball
  card   MATV3 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Edwin Encarnacion /
  J.D. Martinez / Khris Davis CPC, LL   
  Cleveland Indians / Boston Red Sox / Oakland Athletics #64 Baseball
  card    TMH1B simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Edwin Encarnacion /
  J.D. Martinez / Khris Davis CPC, LL   
  Cleveland Indians / Boston Red Sox / Oakland Athletics #64 Baseball
  card    TMH1B simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Chrome Jose
  Ramirez   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card CBT1C _1a simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Heritage Roberto
  Perez   Cleveland Indians Baseball Card
  TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles   2020 Topps Heritage Roberto
  Perez   Cleveland Indians Baseball Card
  TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Edwin Encarnacion /
  J.D. Martinez / Khris Davis CPC, LL   
  Cleveland Indians / Boston Red Sox / Oakland Athletics #64 Baseball
  card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Edwin Encarnacion /
  J.D. Martinez / Khris Davis CPC, LL   
  Cleveland Indians / Boston Red Sox / Oakland Athletics #64 Baseball
  card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Chrome Francisco Lindor 1984 Topps Baseball
  SN99 Cleveland Indians Baseball Card CBT1C  simple Xclusive Collectibles
2016 Topps Update Mike Clevinger  Cleveland Indians #US69a Baseball card   MATV3 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2016 Topps Dallas Keuchel / Marco Estrada
  / Corey Kluber LL  Houston Astros /
  Toronto Blue Jays / Cleveland Indians #346 Baseball card   MATV3 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Heritage Yasiel
 Puig Cleveland Indians Baseball Card NMBU1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2017 Topps Heritage Mike
  Clevinger   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles   2017 Topps Heritage Mike
  Clevinger   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Heritage Mike
  Clevinger   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles   2018 Topps Heritage Mike
  Clevinger   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Chrome Francisco Lindor    Cleveland Indians #68 Baseball card   CBT1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Corey Kluber / Luis
  Severino / Blake Snell CPC, LL   
  Cleveland Indians / New York Yankees / Tampa Bay Rays #70 Baseball
  card    TMH1B simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Corey Kluber / Luis
  Severino / Blake Snell CPC, LL   
  Cleveland Indians / New York Yankees / Tampa Bay Rays #70 Baseball
  card    TMH1B simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Chrome Francisco Lindor    Cleveland Indians #84TC-16 Baseball
  card   CBT1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2017 Topps Francisco Lindor
  1987 Topps Baseball  FS Baseball
  Card  TH13C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Heritage Carlos
  Carrasco   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles   2020 Topps Heritage Carlos
  Carrasco   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Chrome Corey Kluber  Cleveland Indians #20 Baseball card   M32P3_1a simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Heritage Tyler
  Naquin   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles   2020 Topps Heritage Tyler
  Naquin   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Chrome Francisco
  Lindor   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card CBT1C  simple Xclusive Collectibles
1990 Topps Traded Sandy Alomar  Cleveland Indians #2T Baseball card   M32P4 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Allen & Ginter Jim
  Thome    Cleveland Indians #LL-43
  Baseball card   VSMP1IMB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Carlos
  Santana   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Carlos
  Santana   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Chrome Corey
  Kluber   Baseball card CBT1B simple Xclusive Collectibles

Xclusive Collectibles Blog Posts

2019 Topps Gypsy Queen Set Overview

Discovering the 2019 Topps Gypsy Queen Baseball Blaster Box

Join us as we explore the packs, uncover potential inserts, and highlight notable MLB stars like Shohei Ohtani, Ronald Acuña Jr., Gleyber Torres, and more.

Read more Discovering the 2019 Topps Gypsy Queen Baseball Blaster Box
1994 Topps Series 2, 1994 Topps Series 2 Review, 1994 Topps Series 2 Pack Review

A Topps 1994 Series 2 Baseball Card Jumbo Pack Review

Dive into a detailed review of the 1994 Series 2 Baseball Card Jumbo Pack. Uncover unique player anecdotes and the thrill of unboxing classic collectibles with Blox News and Xclusive Collectibles.

Read more A Topps 1994 Series 2 Baseball Card Jumbo Pack Review
Belief, Resilience, and Gratitude: Lessons from Eric Soderholm's Journey

Belief, Resilience, and Gratitude: Lessons from Eric Soderholm's Journey

Eric Soderholm's journey from a young baseball enthusiast to a Major League player highlights the transformative power of belief and mentorship. His story underscores how resilience and a grateful ...

Read more Belief, Resilience, and Gratitude: Lessons from Eric Soderholm's Journey