Account

Cart

Your cart is empty

New York Yankees Trading Cards & Collectibles for Sale

Find, list & sell your favorite New York Yankees Baseball trading cards & collectibles for less with Xclusive Collectibles.

Sort by

304 products

Filters

2011 Panini Playoff Contenders Gerrit Cole Prospect Ticket Baseball Trading Card TPTV simple Xclusive Collectibles
2011 Panini Playoff Contenders Gerrit Cole Prospect Ticket New York Yankees Baseball Card TPTV Sale price$75.00
2018 Topps Chrome Miguel Andujar   RC Baseball Card  TH13C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Chrome Miguel Andujar New York Yankees Rookie Baseball Card  TH13C Sale price$4.20
2022 Topps Series 2 Aaron Judge Baseball Card AVM1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2022 Topps Series 2 Aaron Judge New York Yankees Baseball Card AVM1 Sale price$3.50
2018 Topps Chrome Miguel Andujar Rookie New York Yankees Baseball Card  TH1CB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Chrome Miguel Andujar Rookie New York Yankees Baseball Card TH1CB Sale price$4.60
2018 Topps Chrome Miguel Andujar New York Yankees Baseball Card  TH1CB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Chrome Miguel Andujar New York Yankees Rookie Baseball Card TH1CB Sale price$3.35
2022 Topps New York Yankees Team Baseball Trading Card GRB1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2022 Topps New York Yankees Team Baseball Trading Card GRB1 Sale price$3.00
2022 Topps New York Yankees Aroldis Chapman    New York Yankees #NYY-12 Baseball card   BMB1C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2022 Topps New York Yankees Aroldis Chapman    New York Yankees #NYY-12 Baseball card   BMB1C Sale price$1.96
2022 Topps Gerrit Cole New York Yankees #SMLBC-26 Baseball card   BMB1B simple Xclusive Collectibles
2022 Topps Gerrit Cole New York Yankees #SMLBC-26 Baseball card   BMB1B Sale price$2.89
2022 Topps Chrome Aaron Judge New York Yankees Baseball Card LSLB2 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2022 Topps Chrome Aaron Judge New York Yankees Baseball Card LSLB2 Sale price$4.50
2022 Topps Brett Gardner    New York Yankees #49 Baseball card   BMB1C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2022 Topps Brett Gardner    New York Yankees #49 Baseball card   BMB1C Sale price$1.65
2022 Topps Aaron Judge  New York Yankees #99 Baseball card   LSL1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2022 Topps Aaron Judge  New York Yankees #99 Baseball card   LSL1 Sale price$4.15
2021 Topps Update Tyler Wade    New York Yankees #US115 Baseball card   BMB1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Update Tyler Wade    New York Yankees #US115 Baseball card   BMB1A Sale price$1.90
2021 Topps Update Jonathan Loaisiga    New York Yankees #US264 Baseball card   BMB1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Update Jonathan Loaisiga    New York Yankees #US264 Baseball card   BMB1A Sale price$1.83
2021 Topps Update Jameson Taillon    New York Yankees #US132 Baseball card   BMB1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Update Jameson Taillon    New York Yankees #US132 Baseball card   BMB1A Sale price$2.55
2021 Topps Heritage Luke Voit   New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Heritage Luke Voit   New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB Sale price$3.00
2021 Topps Heritage 2021 Rookie Stars - Yankees - Estevan Florial / Clarke Schmidt RC   New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Heritage 2021 Rookie Stars - Yankees - Estevan Florial / Clarke Schmidt RC   New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB Sale price$4.00
2021 Topps Heritage 2021 Rookie Stars - NL - AL - Ian Anderson / Deivi Garcia / Cristian Javier RC   Atlanta Braves / New York Yankees / Houston Astros Baseball Card GMMGB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Heritage 2021 Rookie Stars - NL - AL - Ian Anderson / Deivi Garcia / Cristian Javier RC   Atlanta Braves / New York Yankees / Houston Astros Baseball Card GMMGB Sale price$4.00
2021 Topps Heritage 2020 AL HR Leaders - Mike Trout / Jose Abreu / Jose Ramirez / Luke Voit LL   Los Angeles Angels / Chicago White Sox / Cleveland Indians / New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Heritage 2020 AL HR Leaders - Mike Trout / Jose Abreu / Jose Ramirez / Luke Voit LL   Los Angeles Angels / Chicago White Sox / Cleveland Indians / New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB Sale price$5.00
2021 Topps Gleyber Torres   New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Gleyber Torres   New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB Sale price$1.85
2021 Topps Chrome Update Rougned Odor  New York Yankees #USC93 Baseball card   SLBT1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Chrome Update Rougned Odor  New York Yankees #USC93 Baseball card   SLBT1 Sale price$1.75
2021 Topps Chrome Update Reggie Jackson Platinum Players Diecut New York Yankees #CPDC-11 Baseball card   SLBT1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Chrome Update Reggie Jackson Platinum Players Diecut New York Yankees #CPDC-11 Baseball card   SLBT1 Sale price$9.90
2021 Topps Chrome Gerrit Cole    New York Yankees #80 Baseball card   BMB1C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Chrome Gerrit Cole    New York Yankees #80 Baseball card   BMB1C Sale price$4.24
2021 Topps Aroldis Chapman   New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Aroldis Chapman   New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB Sale price$1.45
2021 Topps Aaron Judge 1952 Topps Redux  New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Aaron Judge 1952 Topps Redux  New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGB Sale price$2.75
2020 Topps Update Tino Martinez   HRD  New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGC simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Update Tino Martinez   HRD  New York Yankees Baseball Card GMMGC Sale price$1.85
2020 Topps New York Yankees TC   New York Yankees Baseball Card  TH1CB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps New York Yankees Team Baseball Card TH1CB Sale price$2.50
2020 Topps Heritage Tim Anderson / DJ LeMahieu / Yoan Moncada LL   Chicago White Sox / New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles 2020 Topps Heritage Tim Anderson / DJ LeMahieu / Yoan Moncada LL   Chicago White Sox / New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Heritage Tim Anderson / DJ LeMahieu / Yoan Moncada LL   Chicago White Sox / New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A Sale price$4.50
2020 Topps Heritage Thairo Estrada   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles 2020 Topps Heritage Thairo Estrada   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Heritage Thairo Estrada   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A Sale price$2.90
2020 Topps Heritage Mike Tauchman   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles 2020 Topps Heritage Mike Tauchman   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Heritage Mike Tauchman   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A Sale price$3.10
2020 Topps Heritage Masahiro Tanaka   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles 2020 Topps Heritage Masahiro Tanaka   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Heritage Masahiro Tanaka   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A Sale price$3.45
2020 Topps Heritage Edwin Encarnacion   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles 2020 Topps Heritage Edwin Encarnacion   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Heritage Edwin Encarnacion   New York Yankees Baseball Card TMH1A Sale price$2.45
2020 Topps Heritage Aaron Judge    New York Yankees #395 Baseball card   VSMP1IMB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Heritage Aaron Judge    New York Yankees #395 Baseball card   VSMP1IMB Sale price$5.90
2020 Topps Luke Voit   New York Yankees Baseball Card MLSB1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Luke Voit   New York Yankees Baseball Card MLSB1 Sale price$1.74
2020 Topps James Paxton   New York Yankees Baseball Card MLSB1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps James Paxton   New York Yankees Baseball Card MLSB1 Sale price$1.45
2020 Topps Gypsy Queen Gerrit Cole  New York Yankees #93 Baseball card   MATV4A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Gypsy Queen Gerrit Cole  New York Yankees #93 Baseball card   MATV4A Sale price$4.55
2020 Topps Allen & Ginter Roger Maris    New York Yankees #107 Baseball card   VSMP1IMB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Allen & Ginter Roger Maris    New York Yankees #107 Baseball card   VSMP1IMB Sale price$2.95

Xclusive Collectibles Blog Posts

Transformers Collectibles: Originals vs. Replicas - A Collector's Perspective

Transformers Collectibles: Originals vs. Replicas - A Collector's Perspective

Collectors often find themselves striking a balance between authenticity and pragmatism. While original Transformers are treasured, replicas offer practical options for collectors to explore more e...

Read more
Exploring the Exciting World of Transformers Collectibles

Exploring the Exciting World of Transformers Collectibles

Transformers have left an indelible mark on pop culture, inspiring countless references in TV shows, music, and even video games. The iconic transformation sound effect is instantly recognizable to...

Read more
Digital Dominance: The Impending Rise in Value of Vintage Software & Media

Digital Dominance: The Impending Rise in Value of Vintage Software & Media

From Tangible to Intangible: The Ascension of Vintage Digital Assets As we gravitate towards an increasingly digital era, the physical representations of media, software, and devices of yesteryears...

Read more
View all

Secure Payments

We prioritize your financial security with encrypted payments

Customer Support

Your inquiries matter to us - we're here to help

Privacy Protection

We're committed to maintaining the privacy of our users

Seller Verification

Purchase from verified sellers for trusted transactions