Skip to content

Cart

Your cart is empty

Cleveland Guardians Trading Cards & Collectibles for Sale

Cleveland Guardians Trading Cards & Collectibles for Sale

Find Cleveland Indians Trading Cards & Collectibles Trading Cards & Collectibles for Less. 

Sort by

238 products

Filters

2019 Topps Heritage Brad Hand    Cleveland Indians #257 Baseball card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Brad Hand    Cleveland Indians #257 Baseball card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Chrome Edwin Encarnacion  Cleveland Indians #199 Baseball card   M32P3 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Leonys Martin    Cleveland Indians #27 Baseball card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Leonys Martin    Cleveland Indians #27 Baseball card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Jose Ramirez    Cleveland Indians #491 Baseball card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Jose Ramirez    Cleveland Indians #491 Baseball card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Jose Ramirez    Cleveland Indians #355 Baseball card PSA
  ALL TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Jose Ramirez    Cleveland Indians #355 Baseball card PSA
  ALL TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Chrome Corey Kluber  Cleveland Indians #20 Baseball card   M32P3_1b simple Xclusive Collectibles
2016 Topps Gypsy Queen Jason Kipnis  Cleveland Indians #31 Baseball card   M32P4 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Heritage Jason
  Kipnis   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles   2018 Topps Heritage Jason
  Kipnis   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card TMH1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2016 Topps Giovanny Urshela  Cleveland Indians #467 Baseball card   MATV3 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Roberto Perez    Cleveland Indians #209 Baseball card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Roberto Perez    Cleveland Indians #209 Baseball card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Chrome Edwin Encarnacion  Cleveland Indians #199 Baseball card   M32P1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2021 Topps Heritage James
  Karinchak   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card GMMGB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Josh Donaldson Cleveland Indians Baseball Card NMBU1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Jason Kipnis    Cleveland Indians #247 Baseball card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Jason Kipnis    Cleveland Indians #247 Baseball card   TMH1C simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Francisco
 Lindor Cleveland Indians Baseball Card NMBU1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2015 Topps Yan Gomes  Cleveland Indians #622 Baseball card   MATV2 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2015 Topps Mike Aviles  Cleveland Indians #397 Baseball card   MATV2 simple Xclusive Collectibles
1994 Bowman Herb Perry   RC Cleveland Indians Baseball Card BOWV3 simple Xclusive Collectibles
1994 Bowman Daron
  Kirkreit   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card BOWV3 simple Xclusive Collectibles
1994 Bowman Chad Ogea   Cleveland Indians Baseball Card BOWV3 simple Xclusive Collectibles
1994 Bowman Albie Lopez   Cleveland Indians Baseball Card BOWV3 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Yan Gomes   Cleveland Indians Baseball Card DPT1D_1a simple Xclusive Collectibles
1991 Topps Efrain
Valdez   RC, ERR  Cleveland Indians Baseball Card GMMGC simple Xclusive Collectibles   1991 Topps Efrain
Valdez   RC, ERR  Cleveland Indians Baseball Card GMMGC simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Cleveland Indians
  Oscar Mercado    Cleveland Indians
  Baseball Card GMMGC_1a simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Greg Allen    Cleveland Indians #514 Baseball card   CBT1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
1988 Topps Don Gordon   RC Cleveland Indians Baseball Card GMMGD_1a simple Xclusive Collectibles
1990 Topps Traded Candy
  Maldonado   Cleveland Indians Baseball
  Card VFBMD simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Heritage Shane Bieber    Cleveland Indians #112 Baseball card   TMH1C_1a simple Xclusive Collectibles   2019 Topps Heritage Shane Bieber    Cleveland Indians #112 Baseball card   TMH1C_1a simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Corey Kluber
  All-Star Game  Cleveland Indians
  Baseball Card DPT1D simple Xclusive Collectibles
2018 Topps Chrome Andrew Miller  Cleveland Indians #117 Baseball card   M32P3 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2016 Topps Update Shawn Morimando  Cleveland Indians #US85 Baseball card   MATV4 simple Xclusive Collectibles
2016 Topps Update Juan Uribe  Cleveland Indians #US32 Baseball card   MATV4_1a simple Xclusive Collectibles
2015 Topps Lonnie Chisenhall  Cleveland Indians #444 Baseball card   M32P1 simple Xclusive Collectibles
1993 Triple Play Kenny Lofton    Cleveland Indians #144 Baseball card   CBT1A simple Xclusive Collectibles
2020 Topps Jordan Luplow    Cleveland Indians #565 Baseball card   VSMP1IMB simple Xclusive Collectibles
2019 Topps Gypsy Queen Adam Cimber  Cleveland Indians #183 Baseball card   M32P2 simple Xclusive Collectibles

Xclusive Collectibles Blog Posts

2024 Panini Mosaic Football Mega Box Review: Rookies, Parallels, and More
Box Breaks

2024 Panini Mosaic Football Mega Box Review: Rookies, Parallels, and More

The 2024 Panini Mosaic Football Mega Box delivers bold designs, rookie cards, and exclusive parallels. Explore our box break to see highlights, key rookies, and exciting inserts.

Read more 2024 Panini Mosaic Football Mega Box Review: Rookies, Parallels, and More
2019 Topps Holiday Mega Box, 2019 Topps Holiday Baseball Mega Box Break
Baseball Break

2019 Topps Holiday Baseball Box Break: Rookies and Festive Variations

The 2019 Topps Holiday Baseball set combines festive designs with star power, featuring unique holiday-themed short prints, metallic parallels, and rookie cards. In this box break, we uncover relic...

Read more 2019 Topps Holiday Baseball Box Break: Rookies and Festive Variations
2019 Topps Baseball Series 1 Hobby Box Break Blog
Baseball Break

2019 Topps Baseball Series 1 Hobby Box Break: Rookies, Relics, SPs, and Gold Hits

The 2019 Topps Series 1 Hobby Box delivers standout hits, including Adrian Beltre relics, rookie cards, and gold parallels. This re-released break, despite minor audio and video challenges, showcas...

Read more 2019 Topps Baseball Series 1 Hobby Box Break: Rookies, Relics, SPs, and Gold Hits